Some Pig

My wireless mouse died the other night. Spectacularly died, actually. I thought it just was a matter of replacing batteries, but they were leaking acid after I put them into the mouse. I went through two sets of batteries before I concluded that it was the mouse, not the double-A’s, that were the problem.

So, I went to the local Wal-Mart at 11:45 to find a new mouse. I ended up picking up a wireless mouse/keyboard combo, since my wireless keyboard died earlier in the year. I wish I’d paid attention to the manufacturer of my current mouse before I left, since I ended up replacing it with something by the same company, but it worked well through two years, so I’m not too upset.

Salutations!Anyway, while I was walking around the electronics section, trying to decide what to get, the various TVs out front were showing the new live-action “Charlotte’s Web.” I didn’t catch the film in theaters, though I heard it ended up being pretty good. It was one of my favorite books as a kid, and I even re-read it just a couple summers ago.

But one thing I never caught, one thing that didn’t even occur to me until that night, is that Charlotte’s Web is a scientific fable.

So, if you don’t remember the basic story, it goes something like this: in the latest litter of pigs, one is kind of a runt. John Arable, owner of the farm, decides to kill it, but his daughter Fern persuades him not to. He gives it to her as a pet, and she names it Wilbur. Wilbur’s a cheerful and inquisitive pig, and he befriends the various animals on the farm, particularly a spider named Charlotte. When he discovers that he’s going to be Christmas dinner, he enlists Charlotte’s help, and she makes a web over his pen, with the words “SOME PIG” woven into it. The amazing sight saves Wilbur’s life, and its repetition allows him to survive indefinitely.

Anyway, when the first amazing web appears, the family and townsfolk gather round and proclaim it a miracle. They attribute it to some special properties in Wilbur, or to magic–God is never mentioned explicitly, but I seem to recall that a pastor is involved. They look at this incredible phenomenon, and in it they find justification for all sorts of mystical thinking and magical powers.

But, in reality, this spiderweb was actually the work of a spider. And while that might seem obvious, no one even seems to consider it. The only magic is the natural magic of altruism and love, embodied in a selfless act to save a friend. Reality is less surprising, perhaps, than magical fantasy, but the reader recognizes that the real story is far more amazing, far more beautiful, and far more poignant than the popular myth.

To me, recognizing that human imagination can never quite match the natural world in terms of rich, unexpected, awe-inspiring majesty, is the heart of the scientific pursuit.

2 Responses to Some Pig

  1. Dikkii says:

    I just re-read Charlotte’s Web recently, and you know, a similar thought occurred to me.But I wasn’t able to voice it quite like that.Thanks you Tom, that was excellent.

  2. Anonymous says:

    Yeah, I remember thinking, when I read the book as a kid, “Why is everyone so impressed by the pig? I’m impressed by the spider!”At any rate, if the “only magic is the natural magic of altruism and love, embodied in a selfless act to save a friend,” that’s plenty for me. (Well put, by the way.)Hey – isn’t that what Superman Returns was about?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: